Battle 5146 Details

Battle ID:5146
Creator:WJ Palmer
Map:RandomMaps4L_176
Type:Campaign
Scenario Type:Encounter
Date & Time:Nov 02, 2025 10:20:15 pm America/Chicago
Download RM/ Classic
Player Count:6
CS Players:
Benmilam
WJ Palmer
swinder
US Players:
Oc3an
NY Cavalry
Robert Macleod
Result: Confederate Victory
Replay:View Replay

Confederate

Name Status Casualties Inflicted
Benjamin F Butler Rallying 3437 3674
  Leonidas Polk Rallying 3437 3674
    Joshua S Windsor Rallying 1775 2180
      James B Morrill Rallying 488 459
        36th Alabama Lt Col R Spangler Engaged 154 183
        14th Alabama Col B Williams Resting 108 24
        6th Alabama Lt Col W Lumkins Engaged 226 252
      Lewis F Wright Rallying 756 720
        6th Texas Col R Self Rallying 294 212
        2nd Texas Col B Garven Engaged 189 284
        16th Texas Col W Day Resting 273 224
      James Honaker Rallying 531 875
        41st Georgia Col Humphrey Moving 209 359
        26th Georgia Col G Green Engaged 247 214
        18th Georgia Lt Col Gardner Resting 75 302
      Henry D Johnston Rallying 0 47
        3in Ordnance Sgt Oliver Resting 0 0
        3in Ordnance Sgt Bolling Resting 0 16
        3in Ordnance Cpl Parsons Resting 0 31
        3in Ordnance Cpl Dudley Resting 0 0
      Charles M Gordon Rallying 0 79
        10lb Parrott Cpl Davison Engaged 0 24
        10lb Parrott Cpl Alrich Engaged 0 12
        10lb Parrott 2Lt Terry Engaged 0 9
        10lb Parrott Cpl Allen Engaged 0 9
        10lb Parrott Cpl Dennis Engaged 0 25
      Objective Holder Resting 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
    WJ Palmer Rallying 439 440
      Evander M Law Resting 439 413
        15th Alabama Lt Col W Oates Engaged 156 137
        44th Alabama Lt Col L Colther Engaged 21 26
        4th Alabama Col Kennada Engaged 151 55
        47th Alabama Lt Col C Hutson Engaged 85 134
        48th Alabama Col J Sheffield Resting 26 61
      Aaron L Bledsoe Rallying 0 2
        10lb Parrott 2Lt Shortridge Unlimbering 0 1
        10lb Parrott 2Lt Carter Limbered 0 0
        10lb Parrott 2Lt Gardner Limbered 0 1
      Thomas B Deshazo Rallying 0 25
        12lb Napoleon 2Lt Wynegan Engaged 0 4
        12lb Napoleon Sgt Cobb Engaged 0 0
        12lb Napoleon 2Lt Palmer Engaged 0 1
        12lb Napoleon 2Lt Taylor Engaged 0 16
        12lb Napoleon 2Lt Finch Engaged 0 4
      Objective Holder Resting 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
    Benjamin McCulloch Rallying 1223 1054
      Asbery Foman Rallying 729 495
        20th South Carolina Col B Underwood Rallying 172 51
        22nd Mississippi Col P Knight Engaged 208 187
        6th Arkansas Col D Davis Engaged 219 122
        20th Arkansas Lt Col W Frost Engaged 130 135
      William H Houchins Rallying 490 532
        10th South Carolina Col Stabler Routed 260 432
        11th Arkansas Col B Sibley Moving 230 100
      Benjaman A Wynn Rallying 4 27
        6lb Model 1841 Sgt Pickard Engaged 0 2
        6lb Model 1841 Sgt Spivey Resting 0 0
        6lb Model 1841 Sgt Owens Engaged 0 0
        3in Ordnance Sgt Sisson Rallying 4 0
        6lb Model 1841 Sgt White Engaged 0 25
      Objective Holder Resting 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
  Confederate Courier Moving 0 0

Union

Name Status Casualties Inflicted
James B McPherson Rallying 3674 3437
  Frank P Blair Jr Resting 1198 1411
    Robert MacLeod Rallying 1198 1411
      David McMaety Rallying 792 733
        10th Vermont Col A McMurray Engaged 203 168
        5th Vermont Col K Keller Engaged 108 225
        2nd Vermont Lt Col E Sumner Routed 303 148
        18th Vermont Col Kann Moving 178 192
      Andrew Little Rallying 406 606
        1st New Hampshire Col M Tappan Resting 61 21
        3rd Vermont Lt Col B Baird Engaged 202 384
        1st Vermont Lt Col O Little Engaged 56 104
        2nd New Jersey Col B Hougland Engaged 26 10
        3rd New Hampshire Col J Marston Engaged 61 87
      Jabez J Daniels Rallying 0 0
        3in Ordnance Sgt Breyer Resting 0 0
        3in Ordnance Cpl Miles Resting 0 0
        3in Ordnance Cpl Mason Limbered 0 0
        12lb Napoleon 2Lt Young Resting 0 0
        12lb Napoleon Cpl Snider Limbered 0 0
        3in Ordnance Sgt McKivan Resting 0 0
      Richard A Wottoring Resting 0 72
        12lb Napoleon Cpl Donalson Engaged 0 0
        3in Ordnance Cpl Schaffer Engaged 0 21
        3in Ordnance Cpl Procter Engaged 0 12
        14lb James 2Lt Cliff Engaged 0 6
        3in Ordnance Sgt Haberstroh Engaged 0 7
        12lb Napoleon Sgt Britigam Engaged 0 26
      Objective Holder Resting 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
  Thomas L Crittenden Rallying 2476 2026
    James S Wadsworth Rallying 1492 1422
      Henry E Crawford Rallying 1078 986
        117th U.S. Colored Col B Cleflin Engaged 174 272
        4th Tennessee Col Hoffman Routed 306 299
        136th Ohio Lt Col C Milligan Engaged 235 189
        61st New York Col B Sackett Engaged 168 73
        5th Missouri Col S Tulley Resting 14 23
        10th Kentucky Col O Wallover Engaged 181 130
      Russell A Dougherty Lost 414 362
        60th Illinois Lt Col Mastoff Routed 207 250
        39th Wisconsin Col H Pierson Routed 207 112
      George C Gibson Rallying 0 13
        12lb Napoleon Cpl Scott Unlimbering 0 4
        12lb Napoleon Sgt Jackson Unlimbering 0 0
        14lb James Cpl Stibbins Unlimbering 0 9
        12lb Napoleon Sgt Qualls Unlimbering 0 0
        12lb Napoleon Cpl Kellerman Unlimbering 0 0
      Daniel Witman Rallying 0 61
        3in Ordnance Sgt Arnintrout Engaged 0 0
        3in Ordnance Cpl Wilkerson Engaged 0 5
        3in Ordnance Sgt Downaker Engaged 0 26
        14lb James Cpl Buzzell Engaged 0 16
        3in Ordnance Cpl Howard Engaged 0 14
      Objective Holder Resting 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
    George W Burke Resting 984 604
      Michael B Farrell Lost 984 604
        14th Pennsylvania Col W Bangs Routed 267 207
        9th Maine Col H Bisbee Routed 237 118
        147th Illinois Col L Lewis Routed 251 153
        154th Pennsylvania Col Cassel Routed 229 126
      Objective Holder Rallying 0 0
      Ordnance Supply Wagon Resting 0 0
      Objective Holder Wagon Resting 0 0
  Union Courier Moving 0 0

Confederate Division Statistics

Name HeadCount Regiment Count Artillery Count Casualties Inflicted Inflicted by Artillery Lost Regiments Lost Artillery
Joshua S Windsor 4748 9 9 1775 2180 126 0 0
WJ Palmer 2514 5 8 439 440 27 0 0
Benjamin McCulloch 2215 6 5 1223 1054 27 1 0

Union Division Statistics

Name HeadCount Regiment Count Artillery Count Casualties Inflicted Inflicted by Artillery Lost Regiments Lost Artillery
Robert MacLeod 4616 9 12 1198 1411 72 1 0
James S Wadsworth 3344 8 10 1492 1422 74 3 0
George W Burke 1607 4 0 984 604 0 4 0

Specific Results:

  • 36th Alabama Lt Col R Spangler lost 91 men; caused 183 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 14th Alabama Col B Williams lost 63 men; caused 24 casualties, gained 0.5 experience
  • 6th Alabama Lt Col W Lumkins lost 136 men; caused 252 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • James B Morrill's unit caused 459 casualties, gained 1.75 experience
  • 6th Texas Col R Self lost 176 men; caused 212 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 2nd Texas Col B Garven lost 112 men; caused 284 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 16th Texas Col W Day lost 162 men; caused 224 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Lewis F Wright's unit caused 720 casualties, gained 3 experience
  • 41st Georgia Col Humphrey lost 126 men; caused 359 casualties, gained 2 experience
  • 26th Georgia Col G Green lost 149 men; caused 214 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 18th Georgia Lt Col Gardner lost 45 men; caused 302 casualties, gained 2 experience
  • James Honaker's unit caused 875 casualties, gained 3.5 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Sgt Bolling caused 16 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Cpl Parsons caused 31 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • Henry D Johnston's unit caused 47 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 10lb Parrott Cpl Davison caused 24 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 10lb Parrott Cpl Alrich caused 12 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 10lb Parrott 2Lt Terry caused 9 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 10lb Parrott Cpl Allen caused 9 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 10lb Parrott Cpl Dennis caused 25 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • Charles M Gordon's unit caused 79 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 15th Alabama Lt Col W Oates lost 93 men; caused 137 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 44th Alabama Lt Col L Colther lost 13 men; caused 26 casualties, gained 0.5 experience
  • 4th Alabama Col Kennada lost 91 men; caused 55 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 47th Alabama Lt Col C Hutson lost 51 men; caused 134 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 48th Alabama Col J Sheffield lost 16 men; caused 61 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Evander M Law's unit caused 413 casualties, gained 1.75 experience
  • 10lb Parrott 2Lt Shortridge caused 1 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 10lb Parrott 2Lt Gardner caused 1 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • Aaron L Bledsoe's unit caused 2 casualties, gained 0 experience
  • 12lb Napoleon 2Lt Wynegan caused 4 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 12lb Napoleon 2Lt Palmer caused 1 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 12lb Napoleon 2Lt Taylor caused 16 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 12lb Napoleon 2Lt Finch caused 4 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • Thomas B Deshazo's unit caused 25 casualties, gained 0 experience
  • 20th South Carolina Col B Underwood lost 103 men; caused 51 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 22nd Mississippi Col P Knight lost 125 men; caused 187 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 6th Arkansas Col D Davis lost 131 men; caused 122 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 20th Arkansas Lt Col W Frost lost 78 men; caused 135 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Asbery Foman's unit caused 495 casualties, gained 2 experience
  • 10th South Carolina Col Stabler lost 155 men; caused 432 casualties, gained 2 experience
  • 11th Arkansas Col B Sibley lost 135 men; caused 100 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • William H Houchins's unit caused 532 casualties, gained 2.25 experience
  • 6lb Model 1841 Sgt Pickard caused 2 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 6lb Model 1841 Sgt White caused 25 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • Benjaman A Wynn's unit caused 27 casualties, gained 0 experience
  • 10th Vermont Col A McMurray lost 171 men; caused 168 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 5th Vermont Col K Keller lost 91 men; caused 225 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 2nd Vermont Lt Col E Sumner lost 253 men; caused 148 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 18th Vermont Col Kann lost 149 men; caused 192 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • David McMaety's unit caused 733 casualties, gained 3 experience
  • 1st New Hampshire Col M Tappan lost 52 men; caused 21 casualties, gained 0.5 experience
  • 3rd Vermont Lt Col B Baird lost 170 men; caused 384 casualties, gained 2 experience
  • 1st Vermont Lt Col O Little lost 48 men; caused 104 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 2nd New Jersey Col B Hougland lost 23 men; caused 10 casualties, gained 0.5 experience
  • 3rd New Hampshire Col J Marston lost 52 men; caused 87 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Andrew Little's unit caused 606 casualties, gained 2.5 experience
  • Jabez J Daniels's unit caused 0 casualties, gained 0 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Cpl Schaffer caused 21 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Cpl Procter caused 12 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 14lb James 2Lt Cliff caused 6 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Sgt Haberstroh caused 7 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 12lb Napoleon Sgt Britigam caused 26 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • Richard A Wottoring's unit caused 72 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 117th U.S. Colored Col B Cleflin lost 146 men; caused 272 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 4th Tennessee Col Hoffman lost 257 men; caused 299 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 136th Ohio Lt Col C Milligan lost 197 men; caused 189 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 61st New York Col B Sackett lost 141 men; caused 73 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 5th Missouri Col S Tulley lost 12 men; caused 23 casualties, gained 0.5 experience
  • 10th Kentucky Col O Wallover lost 153 men; caused 130 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Henry E Crawford's unit caused 986 casualties, gained 4 experience
  • 60th Illinois Lt Col Mastoff lost 174 men; caused 250 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 39th Wisconsin Col H Pierson lost 174 men; caused 112 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Russell A Dougherty had a completely routed unit, he died
  • 12lb Napoleon Cpl Scott caused 4 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 14lb James Cpl Stibbins caused 9 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • George C Gibson's unit caused 13 casualties, gained 0 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Cpl Wilkerson caused 5 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Sgt Downaker caused 26 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 14lb James Cpl Buzzell caused 16 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • 3in Ordnance Cpl Howard caused 14 casualties, gained 0.15 experience
  • Daniel Witman's unit caused 61 casualties, gained 0.25 experience
  • 14th Pennsylvania Col W Bangs lost 224 men; caused 207 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 9th Maine Col H Bisbee lost 198 men; caused 118 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 147th Illinois Col L Lewis lost 211 men; caused 153 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • 154th Pennsylvania Col Cassel lost 193 men; caused 126 casualties, gained 1 experience
  • Michael B Farrell had a completely routed unit, he died